Cleveland Indians Baseball Schedule, News, Tickets, Scores, Players, Blogs, Videos, Links and More
More Fan Site Teams:

Major League Baseball should amend replay review for on/off base disputes

Major League Baseball should amend replay review for on/off base disputes
Published On: Fri, Oct 13
Aug 25, 2017; St. Louis, MO, USA; St. Louis Cardinals relief pitcher Ryan Sherriff (65) pitches in his Major League debut during the fifth inning against the Tampa Bay Rays at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports

The Cubs won Thursdays NLDS Game 5 by a 9-8 score over the Nationals and were aided in part by replay review in the eighth inning, helping Wade Davis escape a jam. The Nationals had scored a run on a Michael Taylor RBI single, cutting their deficit to one run. Lobaton kept the rally going with a line drive single up the middle.

The next batter, Trea Turner, worked a 1-1 count against Davis, then took a cut fastball for ball two. Catcher Willson Contreras snapped a throw back to first base as Lobaton had stayed a bit too far off the bag. Lobaton awkwardly slid back into the first base bag and was initially ruled safe. The Cubs challenged, however, as Lobatons foot appeared to pop off of the first base bag for a microsecond while first baseman Anthony Rizzo still had his glove on him. The call was overturned, Lobaton was out, and the Nationals rally was over.

The ultimate ruling was correct: Lobaton, indeed, was out. Furthermore, the slow-footed Lobaton shouldnt have been straying so far from first base. He was at fault, for sure. But it feels unfair to use replay review in this manner.

Read the complete news article here...


More Featured News

Francona: Bauer to be activated for Friday start vs. Red Sox
Published On: Wed, Sep 19
Cleveland Indians right-hander Trevor Bauer will be activated Friday to start against the Boston Red Sox, manager Terry Francona confirmed, according to MLB.com's Jordan Bastian.He'...
Indians considering using Trevor Bauer out of playoff bullpen
Published On: Mon, Sep 17
The Cleveland Indians may have a weapon to make their playoff bullpen even deeper.Indians president Chris Antonetti admitted that the team has considered using Bauer, whoA fractured...
Indians honor V-Mart after he officially announces he's retiring
Published On: Sun, Sep 16
Victor Martinez saved his official retirement announcement for where it all started.The 39-year-old Detroit Tigers slugger confirmed on Saturday what had been anticipated for months...
Blue Jays rejected Donaldson trade that included star rookie
Published On: Sat, Sep 15
The Toronto Blue Jays turned down a trade last winter that would have sent Josh Donaldson to the St. Louis Cardinals for a package that would have included rookie sensation Jack Fla...
MLB Must End Teams Purposely Keeping Out Baseball's Biggest Phenoms
Published On: Fri, Sep 14
One of Major League Baseball's latest controversies calls to mind a bit from the 2009A Star Trek, in which Dr. McCoy offers words of wisdom to Mr. Spock."You know, back home we have...
Cleveland Indians have 16 games left to kick the tires on their new All-Star loaded lineup
Published On: Thu, Sep 13
Did you notice anything remarkable about the Cleveland Indians' batting order for Tuesday's game in Tampa Bay? Rookie pitcher Adam Plutko did, and he couldn't help pointing it out t...
Why the Yankees, Red Sox are angry over Josh Donaldson trade
Published On: Tue, Sep 11
The Yankees and Red Sox never agree.That they are now likely speaks volumes to the topic at hand.The two bitter rivals recently a€œvoiced displeasurea€ to MLB regarding the Indians...
Can Trevor Bauer 'beat the clock' and rejoin Cleveland Indians' rotation in time for postseason?
Published On: Tue, Sep 11
It's September and the Indians once again are trying to get their roster back to full strength before plunging into the postseason.They activated lefty Andrew Miller on Monday. Josh...
MLB, MLBPA announce Japan All-Star Series participants
Published On: Mon, Sep 10
For over 100 years, off and on a€” more off than on, actually a€” major leaguers have traveled to Japan for all-star barnstorming series of one form or another. The tradition will c...
Indians activate Andrew Miller from disabled list
Published On: Mon, Sep 10
The Indians announced on Monday that reliever Andrew Miller has been activated from the 10-day disabled list.Miller, 33, went back on the disabled list on August 27 with an external...
Jerseys Hats Shirts Sweatshirts

Name Pos
Yonder Alonso 1B
Rajai Davis CF
Edwin Encarnacion DH
Oliver Perez RP
Michael Brantley LF
Carlos Carrasco SP
Corey Kluber SP
Josh Donaldson 3B
Brad Hand RP
Melky Cabrera CF
See All Players